Street Smart Franchising

September 16th, 2006

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
CONTACT: Erika Sumner, PR by the Book, (281) 895-7190, erika@prbythebook.com 

Is Opening a Franchise for You? Find out with Street Smart Franchising
Franchising represents more than 10% of the private sector economy and 14% of the jobs 

(CONNECTICUT) If you’re looking to have your own fast food franchise, here’s a typical scenario. You will have to have $175,000 that isn’t borrowed, provide 40% of the funds (also not borrowed) it takes to open the restaurant which can range from $400,000 to $750,000, and find a profitable location. Due to the complication of the franchise game, Joe Mathews, Don DeBolt and Deb Percival pulled their expertise in their new book, Street Smart Franchising (Entrepreneur Press, July 2006). It does what other franchising books won’t-it reveals the challenges within the franchise game using rare stories taken straight from the trenches. 

In the U.S. alone, there are an estimated 2000 different franchisors as well as more than 770,000 retail outlets. These retail outlets employ over 8 million people, and account for more than 1 trillion dollars in annual sales. Mathews, DeBolt and Percival offer an in-depth look into what happens during the investigation and ramp up of a franchise business as well as “real world” tactics and strategies for succeeding in franchising. They also demonstrate how humanity impacts franchising. For instance, most entrepreneurs naturally resist external controls and systems, meaning the people most likely to purchase a franchise are least likely to follow the system they just invested in. 

What makes Street Smart Franchising most unique is the fact that it offers “street smarts” as opposed to “book smarts.” Mathews and DeBolt realize that what’s taught in the classroom doesn’t always work in real life. Case studies can’t help a franchisee when they awaken at 1 o’clock in the morning for the third sleepless night in a row because they are consumed by the stress of a start up business. However, a franchisee can pick up Street Smart Franchising and discover high stress and loss of sleep is normal and temporary in the start up stage of the life cycle of their business as well as find successful strategies for managing stress during this critical stage and how to successfully navigate towards the next stage. 

Joe Mathews has worked as a franchising manager for Subway, Blimpie, Motophoto, and Entrepreneur Source. In 2002, Mathews founded the Franchise Performance Group and became a consultant, helping franchise companies excel in the business of franchising. Mathews resides in Connecticut with his wife and three children. He graduated with a Bachelor of Science in Marketing from the University of Connecticut. 

Don DeBolt is former president of the International Franchise Association (IFA), one of the world’s oldest and largest trade associations representing the franchise community. He has served as a member of the Committee of 100 and the Public Affairs Committee of the U.S. Chamber of Commerce; a member of the Department of Commerce’s Industry Sector Advisory Committee on Wholesaling and Retailing for Trade Policy Matters; sat on the board of directors of the Small Business Legislative Council and the National Cooperative Bank’s Retail Finance Corporation; and was a member of the National Congress for Community Economic Development Advisory Council. 

Deb Percival works in franchise development and has an extensive background in writing. Before joining the world of franchising she worked in marketing for 20 years, owning her own public relations firm for 12 of those years. Her clients have included national and international corporations and her writing has received numerous awards for content, clarity and originality.
For more information, check out www.FranchisePerformanceGroup.com. 

I wish I were you…

August 28th, 2006

One of the most important stages of your decision if to become a franchisee is the information you can get from other current or former franchisee. You need to know that it’s very candid source of information about franchisor, market, competition, and even profitability (if franchise owner would be so kind to share that information with you).
 
So, I suggest you to create the list of as many as possible franchise owners. Then you should choose the ones you are going to contact. Try to create a representative sampling – to choose franchisees using different criteria. Choose big and small companies, successful and loosing their net worth, working in big cities and small towns and so on. This will help you to collect more reliable and trustworthy facts about you prospective business.
 
After the list of your potential respondents is ready you need to create another list - the list of questions to get answered. I found these questions while searching the Net (unfortunately I didn’t save the URL):
 
How long they operated?
What were their total investments?
Were there hidden costs?
How long before they earned a reasonable income?
Are they satisfied with the franchisor?
What were their backgrounds?
Were the training and ongoing support satisfactory?
Was the advertising program satisfactory?
Did the franchisor meet contractual obligations?
Would they invest again?
Would they recommend the investment?
 
And by the way please remember that you are getting the information from the people but not from the documents. Do not forget about emotional factors. Sometimes former franchisees can present things worse than they really are. And sometimes current franchisees will brighten up their business. Be on the alert!

Uniform Franchise Offering Circular (UFOC)

August 22nd, 2006

There is a legal document that any franchisee must be supplied with before the signing of the Franchise Agreement. The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) has made such a regulation in order to provide franchisees with material information about operation of franchise system. UFOC is urged to help franchisees understand and analyze franchisor’s intentions.
The Uniform Franchise Offering Circular must be presented to franchisee 10 days before the signing of the Franchise Agreement.
Every franchise company in every industry should provide its prospective franchisees with that information divided by the following 23 categories:
1. The Franchisor and Any Predecessors
2. Identity and Business Experience of Persons Associated with Franchisor
3. Litigation History
4. Bankruptcy (i.e., any franchisees who may have filed)
5. Listing of the Initial Franchise Fee and Other Initial Payments
6. Other Fees and Expenses
7. Statement of Franchisee’s Initial Investment
8. Obligations of Franchisee to Purchase or Lease from Designated Sources
9. Obligations of Franchisee to Purchase or Lease in Accordance with Specifications or from Authorized Suppliers
10. Financing Arrangements
11. Obligations of the Franchisor; Other Supervision, Assistance or Services
12. Exclusive/Designated Area of Territory
13. Trademarks, Service Marks, Trade Names, Logotypes and Commercial Symbols
14. Patents and Copyrights
15. Obligations of the Franchisee to Participate in the Actual Operation of the Franchise Business
16. Restrictions on Goods and Services Offered by Franchisee
17. Renewal, Termination, Repurchase, Modification and Assignment of the Franchise Agreement and Related Information
18. Arrangements with Public Figures
19. Actual, Average, Projected or Forecasted Franchise Sales, Profits or Earnings
20. Information Regarding Franchises of the Franchisor
21. Financial Statements
22. Contracts
23. Acknowledgment of Receipt by Respective Franchisee

The other side

August 22nd, 2006

While surfing Internet I have met an article that made me overlook some of my views on franchise system.
It is called Marketing the Franchise and written by Edward N. Levitt, a franchise lawyer and partner with Gowling LaFleur Henderson LLP, who has over 30 years experience practicing franchise law, is a prolific writer, a noted lecturer and is currently General Counsel to the Canadian Franchise Association.
I used to consider franchises mostly from franchisees point of view. What should an entrepreneur do in order to find the right franchisor? What are the most thrilling franchise experiences in … (let’s say Australia)? What are the main rules to follow in order to be successful franchisee?
But franchise as any other system is a two-way highway. And franchisors also face a lot of problems during setting up and organizing a franchise system work.
Their problems are problems of other growth. Where should a company search for its franchisees? What are the criteria to choose the right guys to work with that business? How should business relationships be installed? Where are the responsibilities borders? What information and authority should be shared with franchisees? How should a company respond to improper franchisees?
All that topics are called franchise marketing. And a franchisor should be clear in his mind answering all that questions.
So the article is a must read to anyone thinking to install his own franchise system and highly recommended to anyone interested in franchises.

What moves franchises and revolutions?

August 12th, 2006

Karl Marx is dead. The inventor of communism is lying in a grave at London Highgate cemetery. But the ideas he has presented to the society are still alive and prosperous. Moreover they are taking their place today. We are turning to them today. If it is hard to you to believe me you have to read Funky Business by Kjel A. Nordstrem and Jonas Ridderstrale. You will know a lot about modern economic trends and Karl Marx. They are speaking about the value of workers and especially about the value of their brains and ideas.
They were clever guys – Karl Marx, Friedrich Engels, Vladimir Lenin, Mao, Che Gevara and all other communist leaders. They were nations’ leaders. And they knew the clue idea that people not the capital are the most important production resource.
And they knew the power of unions. It seems to me that even today we are not realizing the importance and power of united people. But those guys knew.
El pueblo unido jamas sera vencido! That is the Spanish expression that means “United people will never be defeated”. It became famous during the Cuba revolution. It’s the beginning of revolution hymn. And it had become very popular in sixties. Comandante Che was definitely right. Synergetic effect is the key.
2 + 2 = 7.
The system is much more than the sum of its elements.
And united people can reach unbelievable achievements. That is the thing that brings success to revolutions.
And that is the thing that brings success to franchises. That is an American way to unite people.
Do you need examples? I have them.
Let’s examine Holiday Inn. Good franchise system I think. Holiday Inn was recognized in 2001 by Franchise Times as a Top 100 Franchise Chain. So the system is good enough.
This chain of hotels was organized in 1952 by homebuilder Kemmons Wilson to provide inexpensive family accommodation for travelers within the USA. Its franchise system allowed Holiday Inn to grow up dramatically. By 1958 there were 50 Inns across the USA, 100 by 1959, 500 by 1964, and the 1000th Holiday Inn opened in San Antonio, Texas in 1968. The chain dominated the motel market, leveraged its innovative Holidex reservation system, put considerable financial pressure on traditional hotels, and set the standard for its competitors like Ramada Inns, Travelodge, Howard Johnson’s, and Days Inn. By 1972, when Wilson was featured on the cover of Time Magazine, there were over 1,400 Holiday Inn hotels worldwide.
Many think that the main reason of that irrepressible raise of Holiday Inn is its original creed that the properties should be standardized, clean, predictable, family-friendly, and readily accessible to road travelers. But I know one more important reason. It is the unity of the chain.
In 1955 just in three year from setting up that business Kemmons Wilson created an organization of Holiday Inn franchisees, which were charged with reviewing issues important to the Holiday Inn Hotel system. One year later it had been transformed into National Association of Holiday Inns. In 1959, it changed its name to the International Association of Holiday Inns to reflect the geographic expansion of our membership. Today, it is known as International Association of Holiday Inns Owners’ Association (IAHI).
The creation of that organization has driven Holiday Inn to its tremendous spurt.
Today the IAHI represents the interests of nearly 3,000 owners and operators of InterContinental Hotels Group (IHG) hotel brands, including:

  • Crowne Plaza Hotels and Resorts
  • Holiday Inn Hotels and Resorts
  • Holiday Inn Express
  • Staybridge Suites
  • Candlewood Suites

The mission of the IAHI, as it stated on their site, is to operate an association of hotel owners and operators that create a multi-level forum for exchange of information, ideas and best practices between franchisees and IHG company executives. As a result of this process owners and operators will enhance the value of their license agreement and IHG executives will gain insight to better achieve company goals
The International Association of Holiday Inns Owners’ Association is focused on 3 main objectives to help promote members’ long-term interests:

  • Increasing hotel revenues and market share growth.
  • Achieving earnings before interests and taxes, operating profit, and return on investment that surpasses the competitive set for each brand.
  • Creating long-term brand and hotel asset value through excellent brands, quality operations, superior marketing, and team member development.

The International Association of Holiday Inns Owners’ Association also effectively represents members’ interests to the broader hotel industry on legislative issues, along with vendors and other resources, helping to achieve the objectives outlined above.
 The organization that shares the experience, promotes franchisees, teaches them is the key factor of Holiday Inn’s success. It makes entrepreneurs feel comfortable within the franchise system. It provides a kind of support to franchisees even if it has to lobby their interests through franchisor. As a result people are willing to invest large amounts of money (Holiday Inn franchisee’s total investment differs from 1 to 10 million dollars) in this business providing it by an extremely quick development.

Franchise slavery?

August 7th, 2006

Today’s franchises are much alike to set a code of conduct. Whereas ages ago there were knights’ code, chevaliers’ code, mason code or just gentlemen code it has transformed for today.
It’s the franchisor who dictates the franchisee all the way he should perform the business.
Is it good or bad? Does he have the rights to do so or is it humans’ rights violation.
I think neither. Just the same as knights from Middle Ages you have the right to choose the franchise you like most. You could start your business with your confederates – the guy thinking just the same way you do. And nobody forces you to do the things you don’t like. You just have to choose properly…

By the way I wanted to write a message concerning smoking. I’ve found the information that last month Marriott International Inc., the large U.S. franchise hotel chain, is banning smoking in all its U.S. and Canadian facilities. The new policy includes all guest rooms, restaurants, lounges, meeting rooms, public space and employee work areas. Currently more than 90 percent of Marriott guest rooms are non-smoking. The information seemed interesting to me and I decided to make a little research of franchises that are prohibiting smoking.

I’ve found a lot of companies (mostly hotels and restaurants) that are struggling against smoking.

McDonalds has adopted a non-smoking policy for all modern restaurants in 1993. This existing non-smoking policy was adopted by most of its franchises.

The Spudulike Group has had a no smoking policy in all its managed stand alone restaurant units.  This policy is directly linked to the fresh and healthy nature of the core baked potato products.

The Hard Rock Café in the US has a no smoking policy as it’s the law. Whatever the law is for that particular country Hard Rock goes with that.

The Wagamama chain is smoke free throughout its 21 UK restaurants.

Kentucky Fried Chicken and Pizza Hut, has announced that all of their restaurants will be smoke-free by the 17th of August. The company operates 1,200 KFC and 1,675 Pizza Hut restaurants across the country. They are also encouraging their franchise owners to adopt the same policy for the nearly 4,200 franchised restaurants.

Hmm… I wonder if they are doing so just because they really think that way… Or they are moved to that by franchisors.

Anyway as I’m no-smoking-supporter I like they way the franchise system changes the world.

Coaching and franchising: do they have anything in common?

August 5th, 2006

While searching the Internet for interesting information about franchising to share with the readers of my blog I found an outstanding idea that had been realized by the company called Entrepreneur’s Source. They managed to create their franchise business helping others to start-up and operate franchise businesses. I understood that I had to write about it.

The business system created by Entrepreneur’s Source can be divided into 2 parts (as I understood from the information in their web site). On the one hand they work with the companies that already have their business systems. The company offers its clients to expand their operations through creating a franchise system for their business. I really liked the way they present the idea. They explain that they are not consultants but coachers for their clients. They say that every person tries to decrease or avoid risk. It’s natural. And they promise their clients to help to decrease a business risk. Based on their experience the Entrepreneur’s Source is going to train their customers how to swim in a seethed and sudden water of business-sea. They use the idea of coaching comparing their service with the process of teaching to read. On their web site they ask a question: Did You Teach Yourself to Read?
As a sports coach develops an individual training program for each sportsman, Entrepreneur’s Source develop a franchise program for the clients taking into consideration all individual peculiarities. Their package of services includes:
1. Feasibility assessment. Analytics of Entrepreneur’s Source determine if business is franchisable in general.
2. Business plan. They create a document answering marketing, production, and organizational and financial questions concerning prospective franchise business.
3. Raising capital. They help in creation documents and calculations necessary to obtain an external financing.
4. Regulatory compliance. They check if the franchise system and all documents (including disclosure and agreements) meet all the legislative requirements.
5. Marketing & advertising. Well-developed promotion program is a key feature of any franchise system.
6. Lead generation and candidate qualification.
7. Expansion plans
8. And much more …

On the other hand Entrepreneur’s Source deals with those thinking to start-up their business. And they attract prospective franchisees not only for the franchisors mentioned above but also for themselves. Yes, before they decided to earn money while helping others to start-up franchise business (as franchisor or franchisee) they created such system for their own company. And it gave them the experience on how to qualify candidates in order to choose appropriate ones. Now they use the following scheme: they don’t use contract employees to run their satellite offices, but open each new office as a franchised business. The royalty payment is 25%, and Entrepreneur’s Source franchisees pay it from every placement fee – the money received from franchisor when the company places a candidate.

As for me I really liked this idea. The only negative thing in this business is concerned the money that prospective or existing franchisor has to pay to this consulting company. I haven’t found the exact information on the company’s web site, but the other sources say that your franchisor pays them a commission, typically 30% to 75% of the franchise fee. Certainly it is a trade-off. You can set-up your business system yourself or turn to professionals. In the latter case it will cost you and your potential franchisees, as you’ll have to increase the initial fee to cover the consulting costs.

Why aren’t franchise ideas cheap or free?

August 1st, 2006

Starting your business while singing a franchise agreement has many advantages over starting a company yourself. It is easier, it takes less time and you can get help and support from more experienced partner (the main company). But not so many people decide to buy a franchise license. I think that one of the main reasons for this is initial fee that a potential franchisee needs to pay to franchisor.
Today I want to say a few words expressing my opinion regarding why the franchise fee is so high. My observations are based on the following statistics given by the leaders of some franchises:
“Ron Eriksen, the vice president of market development for the Baby’s Room USA Inc., Elmhurst, Ill., provides the following facts: last year the company sends out 775 four-color brochures by Priority Mail costs $14. Only 6 percent of those recipients sent back a preliminary application form; 1.8 percent of the 775 became new Baby’s Room franchisees”.
My calculations and comments:
It means that the company spent $10,850 only for colorful brochures and received only 14 new franchisees (775 requests multiplied by 1.8 percent). So only to get the money back the Baby’s Room USA Inc. has to increase the franchise fee by $775. Is it fair? Maybe franchisee will say no because nobody wants to pay for the others who decided not to become franchisees of that company. But it’s absolutely fair from franchisors point of view.

“Steven Romaniello, president and chief operating officer of US Franchise Systems Inc., in Atlanta, says that his hotel company spends $50,000 on promotion and recruitment efforts for each franchisee who eventually buys a Days Inn, Microtel or Hawthorn Suites franchise”.
No comments needed. Even if franchisor decides to cover a part of this sum himself (let’s say 50 percent) the other part has to be included into the initial fee. The other part will be received by franchisor later in the form of royalty payments. By the way this can explain why sometimes royalty is greater than the cost of current support provided to franchisee: franchisor tries to cover some earlier expenditures.
Greg Longe, president of the Molly Maid and Mr. Handyman franchise systems in Ann Arbor, Mich., says, “Our Internet leads are way up this year, but all that means is that we have to do a lot more work to generate a solid candidate. Most of the people we’re hearing from aren’t qualified to run our concept.”
My comments:
When he says “a lot more work to generate a solid candidate” he speaks about people who will do this work. Company needs to hire qualified manager (or even managers) to deal to convert at least some of the leads to new franchisees. Company bears the costs of salary, Internet and phone communications, and many others dedicated to manager’s work. And as every cost it will increase the final price. In our case it will increase the initial fee in the start-up period or royalty during the operational period.

And initial fee includes not only advertising and recruitment costs. In most cases the main company provides training for the chief manager or key personnel of new franchisee. To do this they need to pay to trainers, to buy some stuff (like materials, paper and so on)…
Thinking about all that things I came to the conclusion that low initial franchise fee can be a bad sign (not “is” but “can be”). Certainly it depends on business sphere and region or country. But at least it’s a point to think over one more time whether to sing a franchise agreement with a company that sells its idea for the price that doesn’t cover the costs. It may seem strange…

Living next door to…

July 25th, 2006

Today I’ve talked to my former classmate who was the franchise owner for at least the last five years or maybe even more (as I don’t know if the franchise we were speaking about was his only one). When he learned that I was editing my personal franchise blog he told me an interesting fact from his business experience. It can be useful while studying a prospective franchise agreement.

So my friend is the owner of a small franchise business related to food industry. When he was choosing the franchisor company to work with he spent a lot of time comparing different franchise agreements. At least he opened a small restaurant and was enough happy as the main company provided everything that had been promised for the initial fee. By the way the fee also was not too high, and as a result my friend had almost no problems with finances for his new business. I need to say that he was an enterprising person with good knowledge of business and marketing. And not only this! He was enough lucky on the one hand, and far-seeing on the other hand to surround himself with good specialists. So the result was even better that promised by the official statistics for that kind of franchise business in that region. He was happy. He managed not only to earn money operating his personal company but also he was doing something for people, he impacted their lives by selling good products they really needed. In a short time he had a lot of clients, and many of them recommended his company to their friends and relatives. It was like a business paradise…

As usual in true life stories then comes a huge BUT.
But as some time have passed he found his business going to shutdown. He really could continue it but the overall situation in that area moved him to make the decision of closing. What has happened with that prospering business?

Unfortunately the business of my friend was destroyed by his franchisor. How could this happen you may ask. Is there any franchisor that is willing to annihilate its milch cow? No, for sure. But the situation could become reality for most franchisees.

One day my friend has found another restaurant of the same franchisor opened not far from his place. The franchisor company has conducted a kind of analysis and found high profitability of business in that region (it was for sure… My friend has slaved away in order to make it so profitable).  And as a result they gave an advice for their next franchisee that he could start his business in a very profitable environment.
As a result my friend has lost a considerable part of his clients who were not devoted to his place so much. He had even lost some of his regular customers. They decided that another restaurant is a product of my friend’s business development. So they have thought that there’s no difference between that two places.

My comment to this story is the following:
Read your franchise contract very carefully. You should examine it on the topic of yours and your franchisor’s business rights. And there should be a statement on the area you are working solely at. You shouldn’t agree to start a business in the area inner competition could destroy your business.

Why does franchising grow when economy slows down?

July 21st, 2006

Some economists have noticed the following trend: there is a negative relation between development of the economy of the country in general and development of franchising (as a system) in the same country. They even paid attention that it is a worldwide tendency. When economy faces its peak and there is almost full employment, salary and wages are enough high and interest rates also. Most of people are satisfied with their jobs and are not thinking about business in general and franchise business particularly. But when economy slows down, stock-market return ratios are low, franchising increases its popularity.
 

You may say that this theoretical information is not useful for ordinary franchisors and franchisees. Maybe it’s so but it can be very useful for those just thinking about starting their franchise business.
 

While buying your franchise business you may get additional information from general economic overview. I suggest taking into consideration the following:
1. When economy grows or reaches its peak the situation is close to full employment. It means for you that you can face difficulties trying to hire good specialists for not very high salary. To get the people you want you need to offer them big money (to make them to throw over their current jobs). Are you ready for such an increase of your costs? Or are you ready to give up the qualified employees and substitute them with less qualified stuff? In this situation I can offer to think about the franchise business that requires less personnel in general and less high-qualified personnel particularly.
2. When economy grows interest rates are high. Can you afford an expensive credit? Maybe it is better to think over other sources of financing.
3. When economy grows people buy more, the total demand in the economy is rather high. It means that if you start quickly (before this growth ends) you can get the benefit from this. And franchise business in this case is better than standard one (as I think). When you sign a franchise agreement you get almost a complete set of answers to possible questions in all spheres of your prospective business. You can start almost immediately. But when you start yourself you will need some time to find those answers.
 

When economy faces a recession the things go just the opposite. I hope my thoughts will help you in decision-making.

This page is generated by Wpkeys plugin